When to use Snake Eye?

What is the appropriate use of Snake Eye?

Recently, I was challenged on the notion that "it is typical to use Snake Eye to get a lucky Phantom Roll total or avoid an unlucky one" (my words).

Instead, it is recommended to save Snake Eye to get an 11 (XI) or to avoid an unlucky roll, while not using Snake Eye to get a lucky total. (Note that there is no reason that Snake Eye couldn't be used on 10 if Snake Eye wasn't used to get there regardless of whether there is intent to use Snake Eye to get a lucky roll.) Can it can be shown probabilistically which Snake Eye tactic is better?

Example: Corsair's roll

Corsair's roll being the only relevant roll for experience parties, let's just use this as an example. For reference, here are the experience point bonuses for "desirable" outcomes based on a tactic of rolling based on the expected value of the bonus if you continue to Double Up, given your current total, exceeding the bonus for your current total, which I have called an "expected value on Double Up" criterion (EVDU). Of course, with Snake Eye available, the unlucky total can be avoided entirely. (See this spreadsheet if that doesn't make sense):

Roll total     EXP Bonus
------------------------
 5             20%
 7             15%
 8             16%
 9              8%
10             17%
11             24%

For all probability calculations, assume job abilities occur instantaneously without recast restrictions for the sake of clarity. Also assume for simplicity that Phantom Roll always has one of several desirable outcomes in effect (Phantom Roll never wearing off) and that Snake Eye can be used only once toward the final outcome. Also assume Phantom Roll lasts either 5 or 10 minutes because who merits Winning Streak? Finally, let us assume no bust-mitigation measures (for now).

First, let's consider the "recommended" course of action, which is to save Snake Eye to get an eleven or to avoid an unlucky roll. In other words, use Snake Eye on 9 or 10. This kind of makes sense to do, since eleven lasts longer and I don't really see a downside to Corsair's roll lasting 10 minutes.

The probability distribution (numbers rounded to ten digits) of getting one of the possible outcomes (shown previously) follows:

Roll total     Probability
--------------------------
   5           .3087705771
   7           .1935656731
   8           .1657878952
  10           .1333804876
  11           .1470336084
Bust           .0514617630

Obviously, with 11 lasting twice as long as each of the others, the relevant consideration is the "proportion of time spent under each effect," so the probabilities need to be adjusted:

Roll total     Probability
--------------------------
   5           .2691905221
   7           .1687532701
   8           .1445362135
  10           .1162829808
  11           .2563719263
Bust           .0448650871

Based on that, the expected (long run) EXP bonus is 18.357% if you use Snake Eye to get 11 and to avoid a 9.

Now, what if you take a more conservative tack and Snake Eye given three conditions: when you are on a 4 (one less than lucky, 5), when you are on a 9 (unlucky), or when you are on a 10? The probabilities (adjusting for time duration differences) shake out as follows:

Roll total     Probability
--------------------------
   5           .4864098317
   7           .1305837864
   8           .1050579060
  10           .0752777122
  11           .1621366109
Bust           .0405341527

Based on that, the expected (long run) EXP bonus is 18.538% if you use Snake Eye to get a 5 (lucky), 10 (avoid an unlucky), or 11. This approach is better probabilistically and you have a lower probability of busting!

For the sake of comparison, the expected EXP bonus if you take a timid approach and avoid busting completely (never getting an 11), but use Snake Eye where it makes sense, is 17.89%.

Um... why don't you account for bust mitigation?

Suppose hypothetically that you can re-roll (start over) indefinitely (and instantaneously) to avoid a bust. Then the asymptotic probabilities for both Snake Eye tactics are as follows:

Roll total     Snake Eye on 9 or 10     Snake Eye on 4, 9, or 10
----------------------------------------------------------------
 5             .2818350774              .5069589846
 7             .1766800353              .1361005051
 8             .1513254427              .1094962435
10             .1217450847              .0784579382
11             .2684143600              .1689863286

The (limiting) expected EXP bonus when using Snake Eye on 9 or 10 is 19.22%, while the (limiting) expected EXP bonus when using Snake Eye on 4, 9, or 10 is 19.322%.

Conclusion

Two Snake Eye tactics were considered for Corsair's roll. One tactic is to use Snake Eye on 9 or 10 (emphasizing getting an 11 at the expense of getting a 5), and the other tactic is to use Snake Eye on 4, 9, or 10 (no emphasis on getting an 11).

Using Snake Eye on 4, 9, or 10 is a superior tactic regardless of attempts at bust mitigation.

By "going for broke" (getting an 11), you give up a sure thing, and the trade-off is not worth it (even if the difference is slight), and this is before considering time spent under suboptimal EXP bonuses in the process of achieving a desirable total.