Monday, August 4, 2008

Do the math

Recently I fought Water Leaper (a pugil) in Sea Serpent Grotto for the Impulse Drive polearm weapon skill, and I took a gamble by fighting it near its spawn point, hoping that the nearby mobs wouldn't wander in my direction. Unfortunately, with about 1/5 of Water Leaper's HP to go, I eventually got aggro from a crab. I was still game to continue on since the crab was EP, but not long after I "reeled" in a nearby sahagin, which finally led to my demise. (It turns out that I-13 on the first map is a good place to fight it provided you sneak pull Water Leaper to that location after killing the sahagin that would otherwise block your way there.)

Since the fight itself is not interesting I'll instead use some probability to round out this filler post.

Each mob's attack round can be treated as an independent Bernoulli trial with some fixed probability of "success" (any result that does not result in my evading the attack). In this situation I could model an "effective evasion rate," or the probability that I evade all attacks after all mobs involved complete one attack round. (I'm not including parrying since its contribution is negligible.)

The pugil's hit rate, which I estimated at about .50 from a parse, is higher than that of the EP mobs. Still, independent events are involved, so my effective evasion rate with the pugil and the crab involved is estimated to be (.80)(.50) = .40. With all three mobs involved, my effective evasion rate is estimated to be (.80)(.80)(.50) = .32. 32% is not that much worse than 40%, is it?

Of course, a 32% "effective" evasion rate is misleading because even though the probability of getting hit at least once (or losing at least one shadow) after a series of attack rounds is .68, the probability of getting hit once (or losing one shadow) is .48, and the probability of getting hit two or more times (or losing 2-3 shadows) is an uncomfortable .20.

Barring a double attack, a pugil alone can only land one hit per attack round at worst. But the contribution of the other mobs is what allowed my shadows to be depleted so rapidly that there wasn't much of a chance to survive.

Here is a case where probability computations don't really belie a situation where it's obviously futile to take on three mobs at once, where one is IT and even though the others are EP. But still, one should be wary of all kinds of bullshit mathematical sophistries that are often left unchecked on FFXI-related forums. You might be able to call a thief on his BS claims that he was able to "solo" a bunch of IT mobs all at once, though.

No comments:

Post a Comment